cjc.jeunes-chercheurs.org/interventions/2001-eurodoc/doctoral-studies-in-France.html
Doctoral Studies in France
Frédérique Voisin-Demery, Pierre-Eric Poble
Confédération des Etudiants Chercheurs
France
This document describes the postgraduate studies in France, and more precisely, research training. The first section is dedicated to the description of a PhD preparation in France, from de first diploma to get to the thesis oral presentation. The second section gives an overview of the PhD researchers situation : number of PhD reaserchers, distribution among scientific subjects, funding opportunities, PhD researchers organisations. Finally, the last section gets on the post-PhD situation, detailing the different opportunities offered to french doctors and their current situation.
I - DOCTORAL STUDIES
Doctoral studie lasts theoretically 4 years in France: one year is devoted to a DEA (Diplôme d'Etudes Approfondies, Thorough Studies Diploma) preparation and 3 years to the PhD realisation. This training is described in [1] (in french).
1 - DEA
After his Maitrise (4 years after leaving high school) the student begins his doctoral studies with DEA. It is a one year training.
It consists in half lecture courses and conferences and half research initiation through the realisation of a research project under supervision. In order to get the diploma (DEA), the student takes an exam and lays out his research work in front of a jury after having written a report.
2 - PhD
After the DEA, the student can begin a PhD provided he can find a superviser and a research subject. The PhD researches can follow the DEA work and the superviser can remain the same. The research work lasts between two and half years and five years, the average length being 3.4 years.
During this time, the young researcher is still a student and belongs to a "Doctoral School" which offers several trainings and conferences. The student has to attend some of them during the PhD preparation. Doctoral Schools are new organisations - most of them were created in June 2000 - which aim at giving a high level training to PhD researchers and at helping them in managing the post-PhD period. Doctoral Schools running conditions are still vague.
The PhD researcher is also part of a laboratory or a research team. He is supposed to have the same rights as researchers in tenure position: computer access, desk, conferences participation financing,... The situation is slightly different in Human Sciences where there are rarely such structures as laboratories and people work at home or in libraries.
The PhD students rights and duties are written in a charter which was adopted by each university in 1998 [2]. This charter binds the PhD student, his superviser, the laboratory director and the Doctoral School director. Unfortunately, it has no legal foundations. However, we hope it will help improving the PhD researchers' working conditions: supervision, fundings for all PhD researchers, sufficient research means, ...
To achieve the PhD, the young researcher writes a report, the PhD thesis which is reviewed by two confirmed researchers. If they agree on the work quality, the thesis can be defended. The student then presents his work in front of a jury composed of a university professor, the reviewers, the superviser and some other members. If the jury agrees on the work interest and quality, the student gets his diploma: the doctorate.
II - FACTS and FIGURES
All these figures can be found in [4].
1 - PhD Researchers Repartition
There are currently 66 000 PhD students in France, and it is admitted that 40% will not finish their thesis. Between 10 000 and 11 000 thesis are defended each year (rounded average on 1996, 1997 and 1998 figures):
Maths and Computer Science |
850 |
Physics and Engineering Sciences |
2600 |
Earth and Universe Sciences |
450 |
Chemistry |
1100 |
Biology, Health |
2050 |
Human Sciences |
2000 |
Society Sciences |
1650 |
40.3% of doctors are women (more than 50% in Biology and Human Science, less than 30% in Physics or Maths and Computer Science).
One doctor out of 4 is a foreigner, 30% coming from North Africa, and 14.5% from Europe.
2 - Financial Supports for PhD Students
63% of PhD students have a financial support dedicated to their PhD preparation.
The most common source of money is a 3 years work contract with the french Ministry of Research. This allocation, as it is called, amounts to 6000FF (915 euros) per month. 4000 allocations will be granted next september. Research institutions (CNRS, ... [3]) can also offer three years positions to young researchers. The wages are generally a bit higher than the allocation, thanks to co-funding involving a company or a region. Regions funds some PhD researchers too, more or less at the allocation level.
These incomes can be increased by ``monitorat''. It is a three year position reserved to already funded PhD students, consisting in 64 hours teaching at university per year, paid 1800FF (275 euros) per month and a serie of teaching training . 1200 "monitorats" are granted each year.
At last, firms can also finance PhD students directly or through a sytem called CIFRE: a business company hires a PhD student for 3 years and receives some money back from the french governement. The wages depend on the company, but cannot be under 8900 FF (1360 euros) per month.
All these financial supports include affiliation to the social security system and right to unemployment benefits after the PhD is over, because they are based on work contracts. Taxes have to be paid on these incomes.
PhD students can also get financial support from associations or companies offering grants. They do not have to pay taxes, but have to pay the student social insurance to have health support, and they cannot pretend to unemployment help once their PhD is over.
27% of PhD researchers do not have specific funding. Some of them have a permanent job while they are working on their PhD (case of high school teachers for instance). It is also possible to teach at the university, but this is too a casual job for a decent income. Family's help, part time job or casual jobs are the backup solutions for young researchers who want to achieve a PhD without a dedicated financing source. But research is a full time job and therefore, we believe this job should be paid for what it is worth.
The funded thesis rate depends on the field. Human Sciences or Society Sciences have far more non funded PhD students than "Hard Science", mostly due to the lack of fundings other than the allocation. A funded thesis has also far mor chances to be achieved than a non-funded one.
PhD Students OrganisationsOne of the first doctoral organization was called ''Etudiants et Recherche'' (Students and Research), in the late 80's. There was a revival of the doctoral movement in 1995 which was set up thanks to the Internet. This lead to a cooperative report writing, dealing with the doctoral training problems [7,6] and to the most usefull resource for PhD students: the ``Guilde des Doctorants'' website [8]. At the same time, the Confédération des Etudiants Chercheurs [10] was born, aiming at representing all PhD students at a national (and now international) level.
Nowadays, there are around a hundred PhD students organisations In France listed on the Guilde's website [9].
III - WHAT TO DO AFTER A PhD ?
Until recently, the natural future of a doctor was either to enter a french research institution, CNRS, INRA, ..., or to become a "teacher-researcher" at the University. But only 30% of the doctors may find their place there, due to the number of offered positions compared with the number of doctors. That is partly why Doctoral Schools had to be set up: more and more young researchers have to find a job outside the academic sector but they are not prepared to.
One year and a half after they have defended their thesis, 27% of doctors have a tenure position in a university or a research institution, 25% work in business companies, 26% are in postdoc, 6.7% teach in high school and 6.3% work in administrationsd. 5% are unemployed. There are still variations depending on the subjects: more than 45% doctors in biology are in postdoc, but less than 11% in society sciences. 35% of chemists work in companies. 27% of human sciences doctors teach in high schools.
The postdocs' situation is hard to study. Once a person has left the country, it becomes harder to know what he or she is doing. But it seems like there is a waste of money in training high level researchers who go abroad and do not come back [11,5].
The young doctors come also accross the difficulty of entering business companies. Doctorate is often seen as an academic diploma and doctors are not considered interesting candidates in spite of (or because of ?) their high level training. This is mostly due to the french training system : on one hand, there are universities supposed to provide academic training and on the other hand, there are french ''High Scools'', supposedly training future graduates for business companies. Things are slowly changing, thanks to the efforts made by several organisations such as Association Bernard Grégory [12] and by the french governments, and also thanks to the recent changes in the economic situation.
CONCLUSION
This description shows that the situation is not yet perfect. PhD researchers are an important part of the research task force in France: almost one researchers out of two is a PhD student. Still, their real place in the french research system is not acknowledged: no funding, or low level funding compared with wages of same training workers in other sectors, poor working conditions,... Doctors' future is also a crucial issue and points out several dysfunctions in the french research system such as lack of forcasting in offered tenure positions or postdocs' difficulties. All the problems encoutered by young scientists have been described in 1995 [7,6]... Improvements such as ''Charte des thèses'' have been obtained but there is still more to do.
References
contact @ cjc . jeunes-chercheurs . org © 1996-2024 Confédération des jeunes chercheurs.
Ce document (/interventions/2001-eurodoc/doctoral-studies-in-France.html
) a été mis à jour le 11 juin 2007